Logins and Media Centers

Just some quick thoughts that started at the start of the day and dumped to the screen at the end. In the office we have been talking about media centers quite a bit – how to create them, what hardware/software and whatever else. But when we came to comparing the different media centers – Windows Media Center, AppleTV, WDTV, XBMC, Boxee – we came to an interesting conclusion.

People don’t need “secure TV”.

It seems that the software that is the most popular right now are those that don’t handle users – they are those that mimic the way that TV was/is watched before the Media Center arrived. This means that systems like Boxee are probably destined to remain slightly niche products (laptop/computer bound viewers) as it is not likely that there will ever be a situation that people will want to share what they are enjoying with others who are not sitting in the same room. At the most, what is watched may be shared between “locals” – family and friends who you see face to face.

The TV is a common space, so those apps that are not user driven (like AppleTV/WDTV/XBMC), are likely to win out as they simply provide a management/access tool for the media. All these systems need to do is to provide content control and they will be all that is needed.

Enough of a brain dump for now.


Posted

in

by

Comments

2 responses to “Logins and Media Centers”

  1. «««««Ž¡Яkã»»»» Avatar
    «««««Ž¡Яkã»»»»

    Media Centers vs. game console interfaces vs. video sharing sites, I guess the biggest difference is that on a couch while watching movies I’m too lazy to type, but I think my urge to share would be the same on all 3.

    1. Raj Avatar

      I think you are right – it’s the wrong venue to try to do any form of intensive input. Even if you have a single login that just sits there for everyone to use (like in the Win95 days), you don’t want to have to login if you ever have to reboot/restart. Having a single login eliminates the purpose of plopping on the couch and vegging out.

      If there is to be any form of personalization, I think it should be done through a “smart remote” that handles the login via biometrics and offers some manner of tracking or sharing if that is required. I wonder if the Harmony remotes are going to have this in the future.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *